COP31: From climate finance commitments to politics of delivery

COP31: From Climate Finance Commitments to the Politics of Deliver

 

A climate-finance pledge can be announced in a single afternoon. Demonstrating where the money has gone, which communities have benefited and what has actually changed can take years. This gap between political commitments and practical delivery has become one of the defining weaknesses of international climate negotiations. As COP31 convenes in Antalya, Türkiye, from November 9 to 20, 2026, the central issue is whether the international community is prepared to address that gap through a workable financing and implementation framework.
For three decades, the annual climate conferences have produced declarations, targets, financial commitments and successive agreements. The UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, the Kyoto Protocol and the Paris Agreement established an international system for cooperation, emissions reduction and climate support. The Green Climate Fund and the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage further recognized that vulnerable countries require financial assistance. Yet the implementation record remains considerably weaker than the diplomatic architecture. Developing countries continue to negotiate for resources that are frequently delayed, difficult to access or insufficient for the scale of the damage they are expected to address.
The scientific evidence leaves little room for further postponement. According to the World Meteorological Organization’s 2026 Greenhouse Gas Bulletin, atmospheric carbon dioxide reached 426.8 parts per million in 2025, approximately 53 per cent above pre-industrial levels. Methane and nitrous oxide concentrations also reached unprecedented highs. The IPCC estimates that 3.3 to 3.6 billion people live in contexts highly vulnerable to climate change. These figures describe an expanding risk to food production, water security, public health, infrastructure and human settlements. The consequences are particularly severe in countries with limited fiscal capacity and inadequate disaster-management infrastructure.
The International Court of Justice’s advisory opinion of July 23, 2025, provides an important legal dimension to this debate. The Court unanimously clarified the obligations of States under international climate treaties and customary international law. It affirmed the duty to prevent significant environmental harm, exercise due diligence and cooperate in protecting the climate system. It also recognized that Article 4(4) of the UNFCCC imposes a legally binding obligation on developed countries listed in Annex II to assist particularly vulnerable developing countries in meeting adaptation costs.
The opinion further clarified the consequences that may arise when States breach their international obligations. Under the law of State responsibility, these can include cessation of wrongful conduct, assurances against repetition and full reparation where the relevant legal requirements are satisfied. Compensation may be considered where a sufficiently direct and certain causal relationship can be established between the wrongful conduct and the damage suffered. The opinion did not calculate individual compensation claims or allocate financial liabilities among particular countries. Its significance lies in clarifying the legal framework through which such obligations and claims can be examined.
COP31 should take this development seriously. Climate finance must now be discussed in the context of both the financial commitments made under the UNFCCC and the legal principles clarified by the ICJ. The advisory opinion should inform negotiations on adaptation support, loss and damage, access to technology and international cooperation. A conference that acknowledges the legal position but makes little progress towards implementing its practical consequences would weaken confidence in the wider climate governance system.
However, the responsibilities of developed countries should not become a reason for developing countries to postpone their own institutional preparation. The process of securing climate finance requires considerably more than identifying a disaster and requesting assistance. Governments need to present clearly defined projects supported by technical assessments, feasibility studies, detailed budgets and credible implementation arrangements. A country seeking international support for flood protection, glacier monitoring or climate-resilient housing should be able to demonstrate the geographical scope of the project, the population at risk, the estimated cost, the expected outcomes and the institutions responsible for execution.
Developing countries should therefore use COP31 to establish national and regional climate project pipelines. These should be connected to their National Adaptation Plans, Nationally Determined Contributions and disaster-risk reduction strategies. Governments should identify immediate funding requirements under adaptation and loss and damage, distinguish between existing recovery needs and future resilience investments, and prepare proposals that international financing institutions can assess without repeatedly requesting basic project information.
Technical assistance should form part of this process. Developed countries and multilateral climate funds should support project preparation through grants for engineering studies, climate-risk assessments, environmental and social safeguards, financial modelling and institutional capacity-building. Many developing countries have identified climate priorities but lack the technical and financial resources to convert them into proposals that meet international funding requirements. Dedicated project-preparation facilities could address this weakness while making it easier to move from approval to implementation.
The geographical and social distribution of climate finance requires similar attention. Fragile regions, remote mountain communities, small island states, informal settlements and areas affected by conflict often face the greatest administrative barriers. International funds frequently require extensive accreditation, co-financing and reporting capacity that smaller institutions cannot provide. Financing mechanisms should therefore include simplified application procedures, grant-based technical support, direct access for qualified local institutions and accountable intermediaries. Local governments and affected communities must have a meaningful role in determining project priorities. The amount committed at the national level is of limited value if resources never reach the districts and communities where the risks are concentrated.
Displacement also needs a more prominent place in climate-finance planning. The Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre recorded approximately 45.8 million disaster-related internal displacement movements across 163 countries and territories in 2024, the highest annual figure in its monitoring record. These represent movements rather than unique individuals, as people may be displaced more than once. Nevertheless, the scale demonstrates the importance of financing planned relocation, temporary accommodation, housing, health services, livelihood restoration and essential infrastructure. Loss and damage assessments must account for these costs, including the loss of cultural heritage and community networks, rather than limiting calculations to the replacement value of damaged buildings.
Pakistan provides a useful case study of the broader financing challenge. Its contribution to global greenhouse-gas emissions remains below one per cent, yet its exposure to climate-related disasters is substantial. The 2022 floods affected approximately 33 million people. The joint Post-Disaster Needs Assessment conducted by the Government of Pakistan, the World Bank, the Asian Development Bank, the European Union and the United Nations estimated physical damage of $14.9 billion, economic losses of $15.2 billion and at least $16.3 billion in rehabilitation and resilient reconstruction requirements. The disaster demonstrated how a single climate-related event can place enormous pressure on public finances, agriculture, housing, transport and social protection.
Similar risks confront countries across South Asia, Africa, the Caribbean and the Pacific. Glacial melting, coastal erosion, drought, extreme heat and flooding require investment well before disasters occur. Mountain communities need early-warning systems and glacier monitoring. Agricultural regions require climate-resilient irrigation and crop management. Coastal settlements need protection against sea-level rise and salinity. Urban centres require functioning drainage systems, floodplain protection and heat-resilient infrastructure.
Domestic environmental governance must accompany these investments. Forest degradation, illegal land conversion, construction across natural waterways and the destruction of wetlands increase exposure to hazards. The FAO’s Global Forest Resources Assessment 2025 estimates that global deforestation continued at approximately 10.9 million hectares annually during 2015–2025. Climate adaptation programmes should therefore include watershed restoration, forest conservation, urban tree cover and the protection of natural drainage systems. A country’s resilience strategy loses credibility when public development decisions continue to undermine its ecological safeguards.
There is also a strong economic case for prioritizing preventive measures. The World Health Organization’s 2026 assessment of climate and health interventions estimates that scaling up selected measures could prevent approximately 1.6 million deaths annually, with an estimated $24 in benefits for every dollar invested across the interventions assessed through benefit-cost analysis. Heat-health warning systems, resilient drinking-water services and improved sanitation are examples of measures with substantial public-health benefits. Their financing should be treated as an investment in economic and social stability.
The immediate task for COP31 is to establish a practical sequence for delivering climate finance. Developed countries should publish predictable, multi-year contribution schedules and clarify how much support will be provided through grants, concessional lending and other instruments. International funds should simplify their assessment procedures and provide technical assistance to countries with limited institutional capacity. Developing countries, in turn, should submit costed project pipelines identifying their adaptation and loss-and-damage priorities, with clear budgets, implementation periods and monitoring arrangements. An independent reporting mechanism should distinguish between finance pledged, approved, transferred and actually spent, while identifying the communities and sectors that benefit.
The ICJ advisory opinion should remain part of this implementation process. Countries should document unmet commitments, maintain evidence of climate-related losses and use the relevant UNFCCC institutions and available international legal mechanisms to address continuing failures of cooperation. The opinion has clarified an important part of the legal framework. Its practical significance will depend on whether governments translate that clarification into financial arrangements and institutional action.
COP31 has an opportunity to establish a more credible relationship between international climate obligations and national resilience programmes. The next stage of climate diplomacy must be assessed through projects approved, funds disbursed, infrastructure strengthened and vulnerable communities reached. Developing countries need the institutional readiness to present their requirements, while developed countries must demonstrate the political commitment to meet their responsibilities. Without both, the implementation agenda will remain another promise carried forward to the next conference.

Majid Bashir : The writer is a Former Judge, Advocate and
President of Centre for Rule of Law Islamabad – CROLI
Email:judgemajid@hotmail.com

Comments (0)
Add Comment